Cover of Mind, Matter, and Meaning: A Natural Philosophy of Mind for the Age of Artificial Intelligence, by Gordon Swobe

Mind, Matter, and Meaning

Mind, Matter, and Meaning develops a systematic account of consciousness, perception, intelligence, and linguistic meaning, and applies that account to questions about artificial minds. Drawing on a tradition extending from Aristotle and Aquinas through Brentano, and engaging contemporary figures including Chalmers, Searle, Dennett, Putnam, and Tye, the book examines the conceptual framework that portrays the mind as a private inner domain standing between the subject and the world.

Against this framework, the book defends a reductive, non-eliminative form of a posteriori physicalism together with strong representationalism. It argues that phenomenal character consists in a complete world-presenting representational profile, including content, perceptual or bodily-affective mode, determinacy, field structure, and attention. On this account, perception presents the world rather than internal objects, and the explanatory gap surrounding consciousness reflects a limitation in our concepts rather than an ontological division in nature. The account of meaning likewise treats reference and semantic content as world-involving achievements grounded in causal history, producer–consumer organization, public linguistic practice, and the possibility of error.

The final part considers artificial systems. It distinguishes mechanism-level content, representational competence, bounded and integrated understanding, phenomenal consciousness, and autonomy. Robotics provides a central test case. Neither linguistic fluency nor formal computation alone establishes understanding or consciousness. Robotic embodiment, however, can connect perception, action, and correction across a continuing, world-involving history, strengthening the case for attributing content and some degree of understanding to the system. Any verdict on conscious understanding must consider the causal history, grounding relations, integrative organization, perceptual capacities, and error-sensitive engagement of the particular system.

“Don’t think, but look!”Ludwig Wittgenstein · Philosophical Investigations · 1953

Contents

Preface

On a school field trip in the early 1970s, I met a computer program called ELIZA. It left me with a question about the nature of understanding that has never quite let go.

Introduction

Minds reach beyond themselves to the world — and from that one feature, everything follows. The book’s central argument, distilled.


Part One — Descartes and the Myth of the Inner Theater

How the picture of a mind sealed off from the world got built, and the single thread that begins to unravel it. The same picture, unexamined, is what makes machine consciousness look cheap.

Chapter 1 · The Mark of the Mental
Chapter 2 · How the Inner Theater Was Built
Chapter 3 · The Argument from Illusion
Chapter 4 · The Transparency of Experience

Part Two — The World-Directed Mind

What experience actually consists in, and why the mystery of consciousness shrinks once you see it — the groundwork without which the machine question cannot be asked well.

Chapter 5 · The Seeing and the Seen
Chapter 6 · The Identity Claim
Chapter 7 · The Hard Cases
Chapter 8 · The Knowledge Argument
Chapter 9 · Why Dualism Keeps Winning Arguments It Should Lose
Chapter 10 · The Case Against Panpsychism
Chapter 11 · The Gap That Isn’t There

Part Three — Meaning, Self, and Other Minds

How meaning reaches the world — and where the case about machine meaning begins: information versus meaning, symbol grounding, why a language model’s eloquence is borrowed; then the assembled self, and how one meaner recognizes another.

Chapter 12 · Space, Time, and the Possibility of Reference
Chapter 13 · The Difference Between Information and Meaning
Chapter 14 · Original Intentionality
Chapter 15 · Teleosemantics — Where Meaning Comes From
Chapter 16 · Language and the World
Chapter 17 · The Assembled Self
Chapter 18 · The Nature of Free Will
Chapter 19 · The Problem of Other Minds

Part Four — Artificial Intelligence

What all of this says about machines: why command of form, however fluent, never reaches the world that meaning requires — and what a system would actually need before the verdict could change.

Chapter 20 · Functionalism and Computationalism
Chapter 21 · The Infamous Chinese Room
Chapter 22 · Simulation and the Observer
Chapter 23 · Form Without World
Chapter 24 · The Conscious Robot
Chapter 25 · The Anthropomorphic Reflex

Closing

What you get back once the mind is no longer sealed inside — and why a consciousness located within nature is the more astonishing result, not the consolation prize.

Coda · The Marvel of Conscious Existence

The Singularity has arrived as an appearance, not a metamorphosis: what to expect as machines seem conscious, how we could ever know, and how society will cope.


Back Matter

The scholarly apparatus behind the spine — the load-bearing thought experiments and the demoted deep-dives at full strength, for readers who want them.

Appendix A · The Perception Arguments: Deep Dives
Appendix B · Scholarly Excurses

Works Cited


About

I write about perception, language, and consciousness — what it means to experience the world, and why most philosophical accounts of that have gone astray. More about the project →

If you’d like to get in touch — an objection, a citation, an argument I’ve missed — use the contact form.